Like Project Fear, fiscal autonomy scare stories. Scotland, don’t take hate, free us with love and knowledge

sturgeon2

WE FEEL THIS SMILE RIGHT?

As London and the USA talk about trading Oil in Euro and not the PetroDollar, meaning the USA Dollar keeps crumbling, Nicola Sturgeon who lives and loves in us all went over the USA and came back a loved Woman who made friends in high places in with our American friends. Scotland is being called almost “Nazi” by the London paid media, here is an example right here ‘UN Human Rights Chief’ Compares UK Media to Nazi Propaganda <Click) The facts are we are a peaceful people, her ways are our ways. She and the SNP played a blinder going to the USA! Check this if you have not already! Nicola Sturgeon Loved up on USA Daily Show appearance (Full Video) <Click) Let us NOT, Scotland fill our hearts and minds with hate as we walk slowly over the hill to a Brave new World, because we are, they can’t stop a power this strong, led by Nicola, energized by our Scottish youth and led by the Educated elders in our Kinship. Scotland know we are special but don’t say it always. We are a special people, Nicola is a special lady, I am proud to call her “MY FIRST MINISTER” Nicola honey, if you do read this, you are 1st an AMAZING Political leader, 2nd you entered our Hearts and we your’s. I know this Nicola. Together we will cast the shackles of oppressive media and old political men who want a last pay day. Together WE WILL walk away from War, Poverty and inhuman people, WITH NO HATE! Just love. Our vote represents what Scotland? For me it’s Scotland, and our love of our land, people and who we CAN become. Don’t stop Scotland, lets line up behind the SNP, Tommy Sheridan, The SNP and the the Socialist party and allow these people to represent us and free our bank accounts, our pain, our suffering for all of time and never rejoin a Union so cruel and uncaring for it’s people. I speak to the people in England too, they don’t want it either, this is why many wanted to Vote SNP. Solidarity is just that. Together we march forward to a brilliant new ending. I hope that makes sense Scotland. Herald Scotland, keep reporting, keep informing and we will help you too… Scotland, we are Scottish, we don’t hate!! 

THIS ISN'T ANGER, IT'S SCOTTISH DETERMINATION

THIS ISN’T ANGER, IT’S SCOTTISH DETERMINATION

~~~Via: http://www.heraldscotland.com/comment/columnists/like-project-fear-fiscal-autonomy-scare-stories-demean-scotland-and-harm-the-unio.128852896 ~~~

NICOLA Sturgeon flew to the USA; she walked back.

So goes the joke about how “Saint Nicola” as Labour’s Lord Foulkes calls the First Minister, went down so well stateside she now walks on water.

There she was swapping jokes with Jon Stewart on the Daily Show, holding artsy receptions at the Lincoln Plaza in New York, lecturing officials the White House, meeting the IMF’s Christine Lagarde, but not President Obama. “Well, we didn’t ask” said the Scottish Government, somewhat disingenuously.

All this adoration of Ms Sturgeon seems unfair. Few political leaders get such star treatment, not even Alex Salmond in his hey day. (What was all that about him being the back-seat driver?) She has managed to combine being an elected leader with being a celebrity. Well, she should enjoy it while it lasts, say Labour.

Back home the press was full of new “blows” to Sturgeon over the falling price of oil. “Nicola Sturgeon’s dream of full fiscal autonomy in tatters” cried the Daily Record. The referendum was supposed to have resolved the constitutional issue, but clearly the campaign is still running, only now over FFA.

Press commentary had been dominated by a claim that the SNP was “running scared” of calling for all tax powers to be devolved to Holyrood. Sturgeon had, the headlines claimed, “shelved” plans to table such an amendment to the Scotland Bill.

“The SNP promised in their manifesto to deliver FFA”, said Labour’s Shadow Scottish Secretary, Ian Murray, last weekend, “but they have barely settled into their Westminster offices before abandoning it.”

However, when the SNP did then put down an amendment to this effect four days later, the critics did a handbrake turn. “The SNP’s economic credibility is in tatters,” said Ian Murray, even though they were doing what he had been urging them to do.

The odd thing about this whole FFA debate is that everyone knows it’s not going to happen. Labour and the Tories were never going to hand over full tax-raising powers to Holyrood. Yet if you read the Scottish press you’d have thought Scotland was on the brink of actually getting devolution max.

It’s like that early referendum which people said Nicola Sturgeon was going to call when she clearly wasn’t. David Cameron has always opposed fiscal autonomy on the grounds that if you give full economic powers to Scotland it might as well be independent. And he has a point. Full fiscal autonomy is a policy that no-one really wants, even though everyone seems to want to talk about it.

The SNP talk about fiscal autonomy because they see it as a step to full independence. Their amendment is intended to call the bluff of Conservative MPs who have been saying that it is about time the Scots were jolly well told to manage their own affairs and stop robbing English taxpayers.

Labour and the press want to talk about fiscal autonomy because falling the oil price makes independence look like a bad deal. They assume – wrongly – that fiscal autonomy is essentially the same as independence, and so they can use the same arguments.

But the lesson of the referendum, and even more so the General Election, is that FFA actually made relatively little impact in the end. The relentless warnings in the press about “deficits” and “black holes” didn’t stop the SNP winning the biggest landslide in election history. And the focus on FFA since the election is doing little to help Labour recover its lost ground in Scotland.

Last week’s Herald/TNS poll on Holyrood voting intentions was devastating. It suggested that 60% of Scots now intend to vote SNP in the Scottish Parliamentary elections next year, leaving Labour with precisely zero constituency seats in Holyrood. Worse, it indicated that 80% of voters under 35 are now supporters of the SNP against only 6% for Labour.

The Labour Party is dying out in Scotland, yet it continues to bang away relentlessly on the same message without asking why it isn’t working. Are the voters just stupid? Why can’t Scots get the message that they can’t go it alone without economic hardship?

In fact there’s reason to believe that the FFA scare, like its parent Project Fear, has actually damaged the Union rather than strengthened it. The rhetoric is entirely negative and to many Scots, demeaning. It is effectively saying that, unlike any other small country in Europe, Scotland is uniquely incapable of running its own affairs and managing its own economy.

Unionists insist they are not saying Scots are “too wee too poor too stupid” but that’s how it sounds to many voters. That is why so many Scots get angry about the press reports on Scotland’s alleged inability to finance independence; they think it’s just running their country down and they don’t like it.

Actually it’s worse – it looks like a case of: “The UK got the oil, now it’s running out, you’re on your own. Hahaha.” Scotland remains the only nation, state or region to have oil discovered in its waters and receive no direct benefit.

Nicola Sturgeon understands this, which is why she hardly bothers rebutting the IFS numbers. She isn’t like Alex Salmond, who used to get riled and would argue the toss endlessly about the economic numbers. What she has been doing, with considerable success, is acting as if Scotland already was an independent country.

Critics say she is running away from the reality – but what actually is the reality here? If there were fiscal autonomy, the calculations based on the General Expenditure and Revenue Statistics would no longer apply. Scotland would be raising all tax locally and sending a subvention south for common services like defence and foreign affairs. That would have to be negotiated as would Scotland’s burden of debt and repayments.

There would also be the tricky question of equalisation payments between Scotland and the UK. This is not independence, but a form of federalism, so even with fiscal autonomy there would be transfer payments to be negotiated as there are in all federal systems.

This may sound like the Scots getting their cake and eating it, but the point is that FFA, unlike independence, does not mean fiscal separation. All financial relationships would be subject to continual negotiation like everything else in a federal system.

There is little point in speculating about the precise nature of these negotiations because FFA is not going to happen. What is going to happen is much worse than FFA. Next year Scotland gets to set a Scottish rate of income tax – but no powers over the other taxes – and an invitation to use it to reverse Westminster-imposed benefit cuts.

This is a transparent fiscal trap. The Unionist parties hope the Scottish Government will repeat the “penny for Scotland” campaign of 1999 and lose votes in the election. They assume Scottish voters will never vote for increased taxes.

But it sounds as if John Swinney is minded to call their bluff and offer precisely that at the next election. And if he makes a sound moral case, he may well get away with it. The politics of tax are different in Scotland as the Tories found in the 1990s. And the more Labour appears to be using the same language as the Tories on taxation, fiscal autonomy and the Scottish “deficit”, the more it is alienating its own core voters. Those voters would much rather take selfies with the woman who has become the living embodiment of the values of the new Scotland.

Twitter: @ShaunyNews
ShaunyNews: https://www.facebook.com/groups/Shaunynews/
My Chronic pain group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/699321140156812/
Scot2Scot: http://www.scot2.scot/
Scot2Scot Site for all areas:  http://www.scot2.scot/index.php/directory
Ace News Services: https://acebreakingnews.wordpress.com/
Ace News Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/acenewsservic
The Celtic Network: http://thecelticnetwork.com/
My Paper: https://paper.li/ShaunyNews/1428021484

One comment on “Like Project Fear, fiscal autonomy scare stories. Scotland, don’t take hate, free us with love and knowledge

  1. Yeah, for sure. For too long we were fully, 100% ruled by London, now we are not. Soon we will be fully apart. Bring that day on, in peace of course. They hate, we must smile back, we can’t hit hate with more hate, I don’t want a Scotland that is free and still hates… But a free Scotland? I know my Kin. We are Pacifist.. x

    Like

Thank you for following my journey...What is yours?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s